Showing posts with label nevada. Show all posts
Showing posts with label nevada. Show all posts

Saturday, January 19, 2008

An insult to our democracy

I think it was a great idea to give the Mountain West and the Latino vote more prominence in the nomination process in the Democratic Party. To do it this way is clearly a disaster:


  • The party is unprepared and overwhelmed by the turnout.
  • Inadequate training: the caucus chair on CNN asked for somebody who could speak Spanish. You're on the Vegas strip, and you didn't think that would come in handy? These structure was not ready.
  • The at-large caucuses designed to make the votes of some people "more equal" than others'.
  • Allegations of union intimidation and suppression concerning this public forum from mainstream media that won't go away, no matter what the attacks launched from Team Obama.
  • A schedule that excludes Nevada's observant Jews.
  • A fixed, inflexible time that doesn't work for many citizens.


These things are an abomination. And a "victory" in Nevada shouldn't count for much more than the one in Michigan.
(Please note that I wrote this just as the doors closed, before results came in.)

UPDATE: Hillary won the state 51-45%. But because rural voices count for more than urban voices (like in the Electoral College), Obama may possibly get 13 of the Nevada delegates up for grabs, to Hillary's 12. This is far from guaranteed, as is pointed out by the Chair of the Nevada Democratic Party. Either way, this system is broken.

Oh, and I'm watching CNN, and Conservative slanderer/commentator Bill Bennett is desperately pushing any attack angle on Hillary he can think of while ignoring Obama. Hm.

Thursday, January 17, 2008

"At-Large" Caucuses: Plenty of blame to go around

Well, Hillary stepped in it, didn't she. Or did she? And what did she step in?

Even though the Nevada caucuses are set for Saturday at noon, many workers in Las Vegas will be doing their jobs in the 24-hour casino strip. The Democratic Party kindly set up at-large caucus precincts for those workers. Not linked to residence, these caucus sites were explicitly set up to give these hard workers a way to participate without having to significantly choose between voting or working. Unlike the typical practice of assigning a voter to a caucus site by residence, voters from anywhere in the state can caucus at these places. Every single on is located on the casino-heavy "Strip" in Las Vegas. As news coverage can attest, this plan was approved by all parties months ago.

Then, the Culinary union that covers most of these workers endorsed Obama the morning after New Hampshire. Apparently this endorsement has real weight, unlike the types of endorsements that Edwards and Gephardt have collected in the past (union bosses that are ready to intimidate members probably makes the endorsement count for more, granted). And lo and behold, some directors of the Nevada State Education Association almost immediately felt moved to sue the party in order to stop this at-large facet of the Saturday caucuses. While the NSEA is neutral in the primary, many of its directors support Hillary -- this is the connection mention in the news. (The lawsuit failed by the way.)

Of course, Obama's people are flogging this without restraint or veracity, using a common spin of "Hillary sues to suppress votes". Obama got so mad about it that he inveighed against "lawyers [like him] getting involved". The Obama spin makes sense if you believe the following:

  • Hillary's campaign instigated the lawsuit. (Probably. I doubt her allies are going to do something her campaign sees as inimical to their interests, and the campaign did join the suit).
  • The lawsuit has no merit on its own, and is just a campaign tactic.


Frankly, this lawsuit was a campaign tactic and did have merit. Underreported is the fact that the Democratic National Committee, who had final approval of this plan has joined the suit, as did officials of Clark County, which include Las Vegas. Why do such a thing?

Well, if there's any possible way to make the anti-democratic institution of a caucus less democratic, it's to set up special sites for selected groups of voters. We're not talking about stripping people of their rightful chance to participate, we're talking about stripping people of a way to participate to which they don't have a right. Notice that nobody cares about observant Jews whose beliefs prevent them from taking part due to the scheduled hour of the event. Nobody cares about people in rural Nevada who face long-distance drives to get to their "local" caucus site. Plenty of folks work on Saturday afternoon, but they don't count, they're not special like the casino workers. The Culinary workers got special treatment, and that is something that everyone should find objectionable.

(Mind you, that doesn't change the fact that even were the lawsuit successful, it probably would have backfired on Hillary.)

Incidentally, Nevada is getting a strong message with an eye toward the general. The three leading Democrats are making several visits to Nevada and are on the air. Meanwhile, of the Republicans only Romney and Paul are actively contesting the state -- two of the three "front-runners" went directly from doesn't-count Michigan to South Carolina. Huckabee and McCain have shown little interest in Nevada. Good going guys -- ignore the rapidly growing swing state in favor of the go-nowhere solid red state that unfailingly votes Republican.

Wednesday, January 9, 2008

Nevada Caucus Rules, or bad idea, second edition

Take a complex system, the highest stakes in the world, a mob of media hacks, and thousands of rookies trying to hold it all together, add in some gambling, and what do you get? The Nevada caucuses. The rules (as best I can understand) are as follows, according to a quick read of the Official Rules (source: PDF) tells us much information. Differences with Iowa are underlined:

As in Iowa, caucusgoers must be physically present at a given time and place, though in this case the caucuses are held at noon on Saturday the 19th. The caucus is open to all voters who will be 18 on election day in November.

This is interesting: any person wishing to participate in the Republican caucus must have registered as a Republican at least 30 days ago. The Nevada secretary of state's website says of the Democratic caucus: "If you are not already registered but eligible to vote, you may complete a registration form and participate on the day of the caucus." At least on Hillary's website, that is presented as permitting caucusgoers to change their registration from Republican or independent as they arrive at the caucus.


Anyway, caucusgoers will form preference groups after hearing appeals from candidates' subordinates in their meeting spaces. When the chair declares time for the formation of preference groups, caucusgoers fill out a paper "pledge card" that indicates their preference that will eventually be turned over to the officials, that they take with them. They form said preference groups. Candidates who attract less than 15% of the total number present at the caucus are declared "non-viable" and have the option to change preferences. (In smaller precincts, the viability threshold can be higher...in a caucus sending 3 delegates, the threshold is 1/6, in a 2-delegate precinct, 25%.)

Supporters of non-viable candidates, and only supporters of non-viable candidates, can then give up their pledge card and move to another group. This bears repeating: if caucusing for a viable candidate, one must stay there, and cannot be talking into joining elsewhere.

There is a significant affirmative action plank to the rules, including gender equity. I don't know if that's the case in Iowa.

Compare/contrast with Iowa:

  • The viability threshold will not have the same distortive impact as it did in Iowa, where 5 candidates representing up to 15% of the initial vote were often affected, here it will only be two.
  • This is Nevada's first go at a large-scale caucus. We're talking thousands of rookie caucus chairs. Though Spanish is commonly spoken in Nevada, a rookie caucus chair with poor Spanish may be in for a hard time.
  • Many Nevadans will be working in the entertainment industry at caucus time. Casino management has been reluctant to make provisions for them in the schedule.
  • It's much harder to game the math as well, getting one more or less delegates. No longer can a viable candidate lift up another to viability in return for something.
  • These are also in some ways rookie organizations. Can the nascent Nevada campaigns handle it? (The ultimate insider's son -- Harry Reid's boy Rory is chairing her effort)