Showing posts with label Iowa. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Iowa. Show all posts

Thursday, January 3, 2008

Yo morons, it was a tie!

A quick note on how idiotic the media is. Can we clarify that nobody "came in third" in a meaningful sense at the Democratic Iowa caucuses? Wolf Blitzer's synapses were visibly firing off the charts at the idea of a "battle" amongst the Democrats (and the desperation from Edwards camp isn't much prettier). The CNN site tells us how the fight for "second is razor close". At least MSNBC had the class to call it a "virtual tie".

Listen, morons. There's no bonus for coming in second rather than third in Iowa. When you consider how messed up the system is, and the machinations ahead of us at the county and state level in Iowa, the difference of 14 delegates isn't much. The gap between Clinton and Edwards is a whopping .49% of the stake. FoxNews, this isn't a "slim lead". It's static. .49% of the stake is a flu outbreak at a nursing home, it's a couple families leaving the house late. It's a good movie on tv that night. But guaranteed, we'll hear ad nauseum about how "Edwards came in second" and "Hillary fell to third". Best of all, this completely ignores the once-vaunted entrance poll, which shows Hillary's clear hold on second place in the minds of Iowans, before the byzantine process got underway.

To all the hypercompetitive type A's in the media and pundit world, there was a tie for second. Clinton and Edwards tied. Deal with it.


PS: Any doubts about the surreality of CNN on politics were clarified by Bill Schneider -- the whitest guy outside a line dance -- telling us how African-Americans in the south will think.

The true, deep-down, real reason I hate the Iowa Caucuses


"The truth is, that the future of our country lies in your hands, not mine.

  • You have the power to reclaim our nation's destiny.
  • You have the power to rid Washington of the politics of money.
  • You have the power to make right just as important as might.
  • You have the power to give America a reason to vote again.
  • You have the power to restore our nation to fiscal sanity and bring jobs back to our people.
  • You have the power to take our country back.
  • You have the power."

The addled cow-herders heard this, and decided in favor of a statue. They'll probably get it wrong again.

Tuesday, January 1, 2008

Kucinich says "follow my words, not my ideals"

The Iowa caucuses held many shocks for the Dean campaign back in 2004, few more than the last-second decision of long-short (okay, no-shot) candidate Dennis Kucinich to tell his supporters to caucus for Edwards on the second ballot. Given how diffuse and low Kucinich's support was -- a respectable but ultimately useless good 2-3% -- he was rarely viable, but his support made a difference to the final totals for the Edwards campaign. Of course, at this time Edwards was firmly in support of the Iraq war (unlike Dean or Kucinich), was wishy-washy on health care reform (unlike Dean or Kucinich), and had no record to speak of supporting equal rights for gays or lesbians (unlike Dean or Kucinich). Although it was not a complete changeover, the body of Kucinich's supporters did go to Edwards as instructed. Now, I don't fully blame Kucinich's supporters, as they were told that doing so would help Kucinich. I do blame the man himself, though. Maybe being a big shot for a couple of hours helped his ego, but I didn't notice big changes in Edwards' speeches after the Kucinich thumbs up.

So now it's 2008. Edwards has moved much to the left, making progress on gay rights, apologizing for his war vote, and bringing back economic populism. He's not as extreme as lil' Dennis, but he's much closer to Kucinich's positions. And lo and behold, Dennis can't pass up the attention that comes with making another move. So he announces that...he will once again bypass an ideological confrere in favor of the flavor of the week, this time Obama. Obama, who is currently racking up a great record of attacking trial lawyers, rolling out a health care policy that (unlike Edwards and Kucinich) doesn't cover all, imitating Republican God-speak, touring with anti-gay performers in order to rack up votes, and promising a new age of consensus and agreement with this pack of torture-loving hyperpartisans.

I'd like to believe that Kucinich does this repeatedly because he's been given promises that we don't know about and never end up being kept. Heck, I'd be satisfied to learn that he just doesn't understand his rivals' positions. But it's hard to see this as anything other than an ego thing.

I'd gather that the idea of running a no-chance campaign for presidency, ignoring one's district for months, is to at least influence the conversation by injecting your ideas and issues into the conversation, as Tom Tancredo marginally did. Then, if you're going to make a move toward another candidate -- and this is the tricky part -- you usually pick somebody with whom you generally agree.

Now, I haven't heard much about cancelling NAFTA, banning handguns, or establishing a "Department of Peace" this year. I haven't heard a candidate consider, or even forcefully refute this idea. So much for moving the debate.

Frankly, Kucinich has lowered his credibility to Naderite levels by consistently using what little power he's built up to get in the way of achieving what he states are his goals. If you're tired of this routine, I'd point you to someone who agrees, and is ready to do something about it.

Monday, December 31, 2007

Iowa 2008 predictions

Starting the presidential election process with the Iowa caucuses is one of the silliest and saddest comments on American democracy. It's a horribly undemocratic and unrepresentative process as I detail in this BMG comment. But there's no way to alter the process so soon (I was about to say it is what it is, but that is apparently passé) so we may as well all try to mind-read these people.

Republican Primary:
1. Huckabee
2. Romney
3. McCain
4. Paul

You can't argue with sky-wizard affinity, and Huckabee's embrace of the most popular sky-wizard in this country gives him what money can't buy -- a first place finish. Romney is cruising to second based because he has everything going for him that money can buy.

As for third place, it's a bit of a toss-up between McCain and Paul. Giuliani is fading fast, and Thompson never really woke up and ran a race. Paul's support is geographically diffuse and very involved, the two key elements to caucus night victory. I really want to believe that he could score third, but you can't argue with momentum. Undecideds are breaking for McCain at a stunning rate, and that I think will push him into third.


Democratic Primary:
1. Clinton
2. Edwards
3. Obama
4. Richardson
5. Biden
6. Dodd

Clinton and Edwards will be essentially tied. She has the largest body of paid staff in state, and Edwards has a lot of unpaid but savvy locals. Given the diffuse nature of this farce, that will come in handy. It feels that Obama is fading fast in the face of reminders of how complex and demanding the job of the presidency is, and he's showing his true colors by reacting with a GOP attack on Edwards being a nasty horrible trial lawyers. If I thought he had a sense of shame, I'd say he should be ashamed of himself.

As for numbers 4-6, the results out of Iowa will be tremendously underrepresentative of their actual level of support because of the caucus mechanics. That said, I expect Dodd and Richardson to stick around through New Hampshire (then both drop out), and Biden to hang on until Super Tuesday.

All predictions guaranteed wrong or your money back.

Sunday, December 2, 2007

Iowa Caucus: Failing International Standards for Democracy

According to the standards of the OSCE (Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe), the Iowa Caucuses of the Democratic Party likely lead to distorted results that may prejudice voters.

You see, for a candidate to receive any support that counts in a Democratic caucus in Iowa, s/he must be "viable". "Viable" means that 15% of the voters at the caucus support that candidate. So, if 28 of 200 voters at a particular precinct supported Chris Dodd, it doesn't count. In such an example, it doesn't matter if you have zero or 28 supporters, it comes out the same way.

The OSCE of course does not comment on the Iowa caucuses, but they have talked about high thresholds before:

The electoral system contains an unusually high threshold of 10% of the vote to achieve … representation … This leads to distortions, and concerns were expressed … that it unfairly prejudices [certain voters].


Source.

(I have excised the subject-specific notes, which concern the Turkish electoral system. The full quote is "The electoral system contains an unusually high threshold of 10% of the vote to achieve party representation in parliament. This leads to distortions, and concerns were expressed to the OSCE/ODIHR NAM that it unfairly prejudices Turkish citizens of Kurdish origin.")

While the Council of Europe has not ruled that this high threshold is inherently an obstacle to free and fair election, the fact remains that such high thresholds are not particularly democratic. The OSCE knows this...why can't the Democrats of Iowa figure it out?

Thursday, November 22, 2007

A quick examination of the Republican mind

Two notable passages from this article on the rise of Mike Huckabee, who I think has an even shot to win Iowa:

"'He is articulate and articulates the conservative message very well'" says the head of the Iowa Christian Alliance.

better still:

"Huckabee's down-home style has proven effective, as has a record that many see as untainted by nuances and switches."

Granted, this from AP writer Mike Glover, but it's accurate. However, what does it say that the key to winning Republicans' hearts is a lack of awareness of nuance?