It was an unnecessary war declared quite some time ago without a clear exit strategy, where the tide is running against conservative dreams, yet it is still cheered on by Fox News and their friends despite all evidence. Iraq? No, the War by Christmas.
That's not a typo, and it is something that needs clarification up front...we don't have a case of a recently declared "war on Christmas" in America that seeks to victimize delicate Christians, but rather a new phase in a centuries-long war declared and conducted by Christmas. The war was begun by Christmas, and I see no reason to ease up now that the aggressors are seeing the tide reverse. From now on, I will refer to this conflict by the historically accurate name "War by Christmas" and encourage you to do the same.
You likely know the full story. The most primitive of humans knew that life was warmer, better, more comfortable with more time with that bright thing in the sky. The two greatest miracles of their world were childbirth and the sun, so no small wonder that almost every culture assigned an Earth-mother and a Sun-god. However, on a yearly basis the sun seemed to be moving away, and weakening. Their god was dying. And every year, somehow, at the point of death, the Sun-god returned and grew again in strength.
We call it an astronomical event, the winter solstice. They turned it into a seminal religious feast. This near-dodge with the end of the world was a solemn annual moment, and inspired a wide range of rituals that would occur in late December. The Incans tied a celestial rope to the sun lest it stray too far away. The Kalash of Hindu Kush still offer dances and praise. Egyptians honored Aset. European pagans and their early Roman neighbors celebrated Saturnalia in late December. Most Romans marked the feast of Natalis Sol Invictus -- the Birth of Mithras, the Unconquered Sun -- on December 25th. Mithras became known to the Roman in the second century BC as a sun-god of Persian background who was born of a virgin mother, and would later die and resurrect in order to offer salvation to all. (Mithraism was as fundamental to the final shape of Christianity as Judaism. It is as accurate to say that Paul and Luke set out to spread Christianity to Mithraists as it is to say they were targeting Gentiles.)
Then the Christians came. Insofar as we can trust the Christian Bible with the label of "history", we are told that Jesus' birth occurred as "shepherds were outside, keeping watch over their flocks by night" (Luke 2:8). Shepherds only lived outside with their flocks while the sheep might be birthing -- something that only happened in springtime.
However, by the early 3rd century, the Christian church moved the feast of Jesus' birth lock, stock, and barrel to December 25th. A few days from the winter solstice and the exact day of the birth of Mithras. When exactly this occurred, we don't know, as the Catholic Church has a long history of keeping inadequate and questionable records on things like historical developments, treasury, and personnel shufflings. So when Emperor Constantine decided to use the Roman army to force Christianity on all, the die was cast. Christmas had declared war on all comers. Several centuries later, it is losing the war it began.
So don't give me this "War on Christmas" BS. About 1,700 years ago, Christmas declared a war in which it is experiencing a reverse. So Fox "News", the AFA, and the rest of you morons, stop complaining.
Showing posts with label atheism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label atheism. Show all posts
Saturday, November 28, 2009
Wednesday, June 24, 2009
Dean overshadows Obama on rights
Howard Dean is showing what he's made of -- again. He has apparently pulled out of an upcoming GLBT fundraiser for Obama. Dean wasn't just some name advertised as coming to the fundraiser, but was one of the four people listed as hosting it. He claims a scheduling issue. I will say that I wouldn't be surprised if Dean pulled out because of Obama's dismal record on GLBT rights, given the fact that Dean was the first statewide politician to risk his future on that issue by bringing the first civil unions into law.
A quick note. As I've said on BMG, Obama's hesitancy to risk his political capital by confirming the rights of an unpopular minority doesn't surprise me one bit. For all their frustrations, GLBT activists enjoy much more influence and acceptance in national politics than atheists. Enough influence that no prominent Democratic candidate is going to openly go fully against their priorities. However, Obama was willing to go after a more vulnerable group -- atheists. That's why I didn't vote for him. From public polling to national representation, atheists are far more vulnerable to attacks than are GLBT Americans. He already one-upped Bush's assault on religious freedom by opening the federal spigot to everything-but-atheism religious pressure groups.
No surprise then that after Obama learned he could go after atheists' rights with impunity, and as such has moved up the ladder to the next group. I'm sorry this was unexpected for anyone, but if you really want to know how serious a politician is about rights, don't ask him about LGBT issues, ask him/her about freedom of religion ones.
A quick note. As I've said on BMG, Obama's hesitancy to risk his political capital by confirming the rights of an unpopular minority doesn't surprise me one bit. For all their frustrations, GLBT activists enjoy much more influence and acceptance in national politics than atheists. Enough influence that no prominent Democratic candidate is going to openly go fully against their priorities. However, Obama was willing to go after a more vulnerable group -- atheists. That's why I didn't vote for him. From public polling to national representation, atheists are far more vulnerable to attacks than are GLBT Americans. He already one-upped Bush's assault on religious freedom by opening the federal spigot to everything-but-atheism religious pressure groups.
No surprise then that after Obama learned he could go after atheists' rights with impunity, and as such has moved up the ladder to the next group. I'm sorry this was unexpected for anyone, but if you really want to know how serious a politician is about rights, don't ask him about LGBT issues, ask him/her about freedom of religion ones.
Saturday, April 18, 2009
Believe in the Bible, or read it, I guess
...the easiest way to undermine belief in the Bible is to simply read it:
Didn't realize Jesus was English. If you think this is self-righteous, take a look at Oklahoma legislator Sally Kern, and decide which is worse, a bad video or a bad lawmaker...
Didn't realize Jesus was English. If you think this is self-righteous, take a look at Oklahoma legislator Sally Kern, and decide which is worse, a bad video or a bad lawmaker...
Wednesday, March 11, 2009
Changing numbers on religion
The 2008 American Religious Survey was just released, with little surprising therein. The rate of religious identification has tumbled over the last 18 years nationwide, and the numbers of Catholics have grown significantly in the South and West (hm...wonder why!).
I do want to point out one line, thought, that shows how successful hucksters have managed to scaremonger Americans about atheism:
This explains a lot of the braying mismatches between theists' views of their communities and the reality. Through this ongoing campaign of intimidation, lies, and harassment, theists have successfully made Americans reluctant to self-identify as theists, for now. However, it certainly hasn't kept Americans from becoming more and more atheistic. In the way that counts, atheism and agnoticism are sweeping across this country.
If you want to play with the data and see just how godless the northeast is, hit up USA TODAY. One odd stat: the states that experiences the greatest jump in "no religion" as a response since 1980 are in order: Vermont, New Hampshire, Delaware, Maine, Massachusetts...and Wyoming.
(H/T Pharyngula)
I do want to point out one line, thought, that shows how successful hucksters have managed to scaremonger Americans about atheism:
Only 1.6 percent of Americans call themselves atheist or agnostic. But based on stated beliefs, 12 percent are atheist (no God) or agnostic (unsure), while 12 percent more are deistic (believe in a higher power but not a personal God). The number of outright atheists has nearly doubled since 2001, from 900 thousand to 1.6 million. Twenty-seven percent of Americans do not expect a religious funeral at their death.
This explains a lot of the braying mismatches between theists' views of their communities and the reality. Through this ongoing campaign of intimidation, lies, and harassment, theists have successfully made Americans reluctant to self-identify as theists, for now. However, it certainly hasn't kept Americans from becoming more and more atheistic. In the way that counts, atheism and agnoticism are sweeping across this country.
If you want to play with the data and see just how godless the northeast is, hit up USA TODAY. One odd stat: the states that experiences the greatest jump in "no religion" as a response since 1980 are in order: Vermont, New Hampshire, Delaware, Maine, Massachusetts...and Wyoming.
(H/T Pharyngula)
Saturday, February 28, 2009
Richard, come here, we need you
I would take a second to note that Richard Dawkins, one of our least apologetic atheists, is going on a speaking tour this spring, and coming to North America. If you check out his schedule, he is going to Omaha and Norman, Oklahoma, a town whose existence was until a minute ago unknown to me. So he's hitting the troglodyte belt, but is he coming to the northeast? Noooooo.
I'm all for spreading the word and turning back to lies, but why not spend a night among people eager to hear your thoughts?
PS: To show you how godlike this man is, he will apparently be in California and Oklahoma simultaneously. Apparently he's trying to horn in on God's "omnipresence" gambit.
PPS: Is Al Franken going to be seated in his Senate seat in his lifetime? What's to keep the GOP from pulling this crap no matter the margin of a Democratic victor? They could delay the seating of a dozen members this way...
I'm all for spreading the word and turning back to lies, but why not spend a night among people eager to hear your thoughts?
PS: To show you how godlike this man is, he will apparently be in California and Oklahoma simultaneously. Apparently he's trying to horn in on God's "omnipresence" gambit.
PPS: Is Al Franken going to be seated in his Senate seat in his lifetime? What's to keep the GOP from pulling this crap no matter the margin of a Democratic victor? They could delay the seating of a dozen members this way...
Wednesday, July 16, 2008
The danger of militancy
PZ Myers, author of the lovely science blog pharyngula, has gotten himself into heaps of trouble lately. His blog regularly takes on theocracy, particularly in the promotion of "intelligent design", the latest disguise under which theocrats seek to sneak creationism into their schools. For a college professor, he ends up involved in a fair bit of capers, not least of this wonderful anecdote whereby he is ejected from a creationist screening while celebrated atheist author Richard Dawkins saunters right past the bouncer. I typically enjoy reading his stuff, and think you should, too.
What has landed Myers into hot water is this post that ruminates on the high esteem upon which the Eucharist is placed in the Catholic Church, particularly in the backdrop of the persecution aimed at a Webster Cook for attempting to smuggle the Eucharist out of Church. It has resulted in near violence, and an open invitation from his college to harass him.
Myers opines:
For me, atheism is the best explanation for the universe as I know and live it. I really don't care if I'm the only one, or one in 5 billion. Atheism works great for me, just as Hinduism worked great for Gandhi and Christianity worked great for Mother Teresa. While I bristle at the thought of anyone (including certain presidential candidates) shoving their religion down my throat, I've no truck with anyone worshiping invisible sky wizards with two, six, or no arms, that doesn't concern me. I disagree with them, sure, and that's why I don't go to worship ceremonies. But hey, I also disagree with many folks on Coke v. Pepsi. Doesn't mean it's something about which I'm going to get excited, because the two have about equal importance in my mind. Long as I can live an atheist life and drink Pepsi, I'm fine. If others don't want to, that's cool. Just live and let live -- that's what I like to think atheism is about at its finest.
But Myers isn't letting anyone live right now. He's going overboard here, and slipping from enthusiastic defense to miltancy -- aggressively and instinctively promoting a certain idea with no concern for the reasons or benefits thereof. Many folks are chomping at the bit to herald this a new age of militant atheism now that folks such as Myers, Dawkins, Sam Harris, Christopher Hitchens, and others are starting to speak confidently and clearly of that understanding of the universe. Most of the time, those calls of militancy and extremism are mere propoganda and misunderstanding, confusing a demand to be heard with a demand to be obeyed. But with this move, Myers has given some substance to these depictions.
Thankfully, idiots such as Bill Donohue of the Catholic League have promptly gone overboard, with he and his kin attempting to leverage all possible gain from this episode. There are organized campaigns trying to get Myers fired, or outright killed.
I still think Myers is wrong, but boy are those who disagree with him so much more wrong! Such is the danger of militancy, particularly in large groups.
What has landed Myers into hot water is this post that ruminates on the high esteem upon which the Eucharist is placed in the Catholic Church, particularly in the backdrop of the persecution aimed at a Webster Cook for attempting to smuggle the Eucharist out of Church. It has resulted in near violence, and an open invitation from his college to harass him.
Myers opines:
I find this all utterly unbelievable. It's like Dark Age superstition and malice, all thriving with the endorsement of secular institutions here in 21st century America. It is a culture of deluded lunatics calling the shots and making human beings dance to their mythical bunkum.Not the language I'd use, but the sentiment is one with which I can agree. My agreement with Myers stops when he continues
Can anyone out there score me some consecrated communion wafers?...if any of you would be willing to do what it takes to get me some, or even one, and mail it to me, I'll show you sacrilege, gladly, and with much fanfare...treat it with profound disrespect and heinous cracker abuse, all photographed and presented here on the web. I shall do so joyfully and with laughter in my heart.I just can't understand what Myers, or any non-Catholic, gains by abusing a Catholic holy symbol. It would annoy and/or enrage Catholics, but it does not advance religious understanding nor it does not clarify the contradictions inherent in Christianity. It doesn't help the world, and it doesn't promote atheism. All it does is prove that an atheist can be as spiteful, mean, and vitriolic as any theocrat.
For me, atheism is the best explanation for the universe as I know and live it. I really don't care if I'm the only one, or one in 5 billion. Atheism works great for me, just as Hinduism worked great for Gandhi and Christianity worked great for Mother Teresa. While I bristle at the thought of anyone (including certain presidential candidates) shoving their religion down my throat, I've no truck with anyone worshiping invisible sky wizards with two, six, or no arms, that doesn't concern me. I disagree with them, sure, and that's why I don't go to worship ceremonies. But hey, I also disagree with many folks on Coke v. Pepsi. Doesn't mean it's something about which I'm going to get excited, because the two have about equal importance in my mind. Long as I can live an atheist life and drink Pepsi, I'm fine. If others don't want to, that's cool. Just live and let live -- that's what I like to think atheism is about at its finest.
But Myers isn't letting anyone live right now. He's going overboard here, and slipping from enthusiastic defense to miltancy -- aggressively and instinctively promoting a certain idea with no concern for the reasons or benefits thereof. Many folks are chomping at the bit to herald this a new age of militant atheism now that folks such as Myers, Dawkins, Sam Harris, Christopher Hitchens, and others are starting to speak confidently and clearly of that understanding of the universe. Most of the time, those calls of militancy and extremism are mere propoganda and misunderstanding, confusing a demand to be heard with a demand to be obeyed. But with this move, Myers has given some substance to these depictions.
Thankfully, idiots such as Bill Donohue of the Catholic League have promptly gone overboard, with he and his kin attempting to leverage all possible gain from this episode. There are organized campaigns trying to get Myers fired, or outright killed.
I still think Myers is wrong, but boy are those who disagree with him so much more wrong! Such is the danger of militancy, particularly in large groups.
Thursday, July 3, 2008
On the other hand...
...the money that was destined for Obama's campaign is now available to deserving folks such as Americans United, Ed O'Reilly, and Mark Begich. So it all works out.
Sunday, June 22, 2008
Secularists need not apply
In January, I felt that there were many reasons I didn't want Barack Obama as the nominee of my party. But the number one was always an unsure embrace of American secularism. More than any serious Democratic candidate that I could remember, Obama always seem ready to throw in with the Republican interpretation that Christians get special treatment in our country. So recently, I read Obama's description of a meeting with evangelical "leaders"...
Who is "they"? John Hagee's publisher. A man who pushes "therapy" for gays and lesbians. TD Jakes, opulent hustler in the name of God.
Obama is currying favor with the nastiest, vilest shards of American Christianity, and it makes me sick. I hope it's just talk, but I'm not convinced.
I opened up the meeting by quoting Ronald Reagan which was saying, I know you can't endorse me, but I endorse you. I endorse the good works that are being done, the wonderful ministries that are taking place all across the country and my goal here is just to have a dialogue to listen, to learn, to share my faith journey and I think people came out of it, not necessarily agreeing with me on every issue, but I think that they recognized that I respected them, I respected their faith, I respected what they're trying to achieve.
Who is "they"? John Hagee's publisher. A man who pushes "therapy" for gays and lesbians. TD Jakes, opulent hustler in the name of God.
Obama is currying favor with the nastiest, vilest shards of American Christianity, and it makes me sick. I hope it's just talk, but I'm not convinced.
Saturday, May 24, 2008
Really fun hacking
I presume this is hacking. Or it's kinda funny. Pharyngula -- which you should be reading at least once a week -- pointed me to this site which is exclusively dedicated to asking respondents if they believe in God. Whatever God means to them.
Everything is broken down by country. Most of the statistics are vanilla if mildly interesting, but I like the following:
At least one vote from the Vatican City domain was recorded as a no.
Everything is broken down by country. Most of the statistics are vanilla if mildly interesting, but I like the following:
At least one vote from the Vatican City domain was recorded as a no.
Monday, April 14, 2008
Obama and religion
At this point, famous words from the would-be presumed nominee of the Democratic Party:
I want to highlight the phrase "...it's not surprising then they get bitter, they cling to guns or religion..."
This surprised me, because my number one problem with Senator Obama has been his willingness to accept Republican framing on religion. He's enthusiastically embraced the idea of Democrats shoving religion into the public sphere for while now. The only line I remember from his 2004 speech at the convention -- during which I was in attendance in the convention hall -- was his remark that "we worship an 'awesome God' in the Blue states." I remember that it gave me the willies: had Obama never met a Hindu, Buddhist, or atheist in his lifetime in these blue states? What was this code for Christian triumphalism doing in the keynote address of the Democratic National Convention? Obama pretty much lost me at that moment, and hasn't done much to win me back on this score.
So I'm oddly relieved by his assertion about people's motives for religion -- not even faith, but religion. It certainly reads to me that Obama sees many as holding onto religion to provide assurance through rough economic times -- it's not heartfelt, but insurance. The statement is a much gentler phrasing of Jesse Ventura's rumination that "organized religion is a sham and a crutch for weak-minded people who need strength in numbers."
From a general election perspective, Obama's statement is a groaner. The Democratic Party has poured millions into counteracting this perception of elitism, and Obama just pissed a lot of it away -- while also whizzing on rising Democratic stars such as Heath Shuler, Rocky Anderson, and Jon Tester. This idea that he (and maybe most Democrats) has embraced religion as a naked electoral ploy to coutneract Republican sincerity is not one that Democrats want sustained by anyone on their side.
However, as an American atheist, I find that concept to be a relief. Did I mention that we atheists are not considered that electable? This is why.
You go into these small towns in Pennsylvania and, like a lot of small towns in the Midwest, the jobs have been gone now for 25 years...and it's not surprising then they get bitter, they cling to guns or religion or antipathy toward people who aren't like them or anti-immigrant sentiment or anti-trade sentiment as a way to explain their frustrations.
I want to highlight the phrase "...it's not surprising then they get bitter, they cling to guns or religion..."
This surprised me, because my number one problem with Senator Obama has been his willingness to accept Republican framing on religion. He's enthusiastically embraced the idea of Democrats shoving religion into the public sphere for while now. The only line I remember from his 2004 speech at the convention -- during which I was in attendance in the convention hall -- was his remark that "we worship an 'awesome God' in the Blue states." I remember that it gave me the willies: had Obama never met a Hindu, Buddhist, or atheist in his lifetime in these blue states? What was this code for Christian triumphalism doing in the keynote address of the Democratic National Convention? Obama pretty much lost me at that moment, and hasn't done much to win me back on this score.
So I'm oddly relieved by his assertion about people's motives for religion -- not even faith, but religion. It certainly reads to me that Obama sees many as holding onto religion to provide assurance through rough economic times -- it's not heartfelt, but insurance. The statement is a much gentler phrasing of Jesse Ventura's rumination that "organized religion is a sham and a crutch for weak-minded people who need strength in numbers."
From a general election perspective, Obama's statement is a groaner. The Democratic Party has poured millions into counteracting this perception of elitism, and Obama just pissed a lot of it away -- while also whizzing on rising Democratic stars such as Heath Shuler, Rocky Anderson, and Jon Tester. This idea that he (and maybe most Democrats) has embraced religion as a naked electoral ploy to coutneract Republican sincerity is not one that Democrats want sustained by anyone on their side.
However, as an American atheist, I find that concept to be a relief. Did I mention that we atheists are not considered that electable? This is why.
Sunday, April 13, 2008
Jumping on the outrage bandwagon
If you haven't heard about this by now, well, now you have...
To her credit, a week later Rep. Davis apologized to Sherman, offering the excuse that she'd just received some bad news...which caused her to take it out on the person sitting in front of her shortly thereafter.
Of course, had the person in the seat been Jewish or even gay, this would have been national news. But since it's only an atheist, it's confined to a corner of the Internet. Particularly upsetting to many of us, I'd wager, is the fact that it was a Democrat who spewed this bile. Democrats are still pretty weak on the separation of church and state, and they're the good guys.
Oh, unsurprisingly, she's in Barack Obama's corner. I'm sure this is due to their shared Illinois base and African-American base. And while I'm not into the game where Obama and Clinton are expected to denounce every crazy who they've met, this does little to assuage some of my concerns that Obama is surrendering the issue of separation of church and state to Republicans.
Rep. Monique Davis (D-Chicago) interrupted atheist activist Rob Sherman during his testimony Wednesday afternoon before the House State Government Administration Committee in Springfield and told him, "What you have to spew and spread is extremely dangerous . . . it's dangerous for our children to even know that your philosophy exists!
"This is the Land of Lincoln where people believe in God," Davis said. "Get out of that seat . . . You have no right to be here! We believe in something. You believe in destroying! You believe in destroying what this state was built upon."
To her credit, a week later Rep. Davis apologized to Sherman, offering the excuse that she'd just received some bad news...which caused her to take it out on the person sitting in front of her shortly thereafter.
Of course, had the person in the seat been Jewish or even gay, this would have been national news. But since it's only an atheist, it's confined to a corner of the Internet. Particularly upsetting to many of us, I'd wager, is the fact that it was a Democrat who spewed this bile. Democrats are still pretty weak on the separation of church and state, and they're the good guys.
Oh, unsurprisingly, she's in Barack Obama's corner. I'm sure this is due to their shared Illinois base and African-American base. And while I'm not into the game where Obama and Clinton are expected to denounce every crazy who they've met, this does little to assuage some of my concerns that Obama is surrendering the issue of separation of church and state to Republicans.
Tuesday, February 26, 2008
"Unaffiliated" on the rise among American religions
You really need to dig through the copious reportage on the massive study on American religion recently released by the Pew Trust on Religion and Public Life. This typical article from the Brisbane Times emphasizes how quickly Americans are changing their religion with this graf:
Not too dissimilar is the closer-to-home Globe coverage, focused thusly:
Let's look at this so-called fluidity. Below is a handy chart of the major traditions in America looking at movements into and out the traditions:
Even more remarkable is a comparison of these net changes as a function of adults' movements from one tradition to the other:
This is not a story about "changing religion" or fluidity. This survey says two things:
Now, while non-affiliation doesn't necessarily mean atheism or even agnosticism, Americans are abandoning their religious orders in droves, and many of them are seeking solace in relating to each other, rather than a distant and uninterested God.
Not that the media would ever admit that.
The report, published on Monday, found a constantly shifting landscape of religious loyalties, with the Roman Catholic Church losing more adherents than any other single US religious group.
Not too dissimilar is the closer-to-home Globe coverage, focused thusly:
The study, which is the most comprehensive such examination of the country in at least a half century, finds that the United States is in the midst of a period of unprecedented religious fluidity, in which 44 percent of American adults have left the denomination of their childhood for another denomination, another faith, or no faith at all.
Let's look at this so-called fluidity. Below is a handy chart of the major traditions in America looking at movements into and out the traditions:
| Religious affiliation | % Americans who've joined | % who've left | net change |
| All Protestant | 8.4 | 11.0-2.6 | |
| Roman Catholic | 2.6 | 10.1-7.5 | |
| Mormon | 0.4 | 0.5-0.1 | |
| Jewish | 0.3 | 0.5-0.2 | |
| Non-affiliated | 12.7 | 3.9+8.8 |
Even more remarkable is a comparison of these net changes as a function of adults' movements from one tradition to the other:
| Religious affiliation | % change within community due to movement in or out of the tradition |
| All Protestant | -4.8 |
| Roman Catholic | -23.8 |
| Mormon | -5.6|
| Jewish | -10.5|
| Non-affiliated | +82.3 |
This is not a story about "changing religion" or fluidity. This survey says two things:
- Americans are fleeing the Catholic Church in stunning numbers, and are leaving the Jewish tradition is surprising amounts as well.
- More significantly, Americans from all religious traditions are losing interest in religious affiliation...in enormous numbers.
Now, while non-affiliation doesn't necessarily mean atheism or even agnosticism, Americans are abandoning their religious orders in droves, and many of them are seeking solace in relating to each other, rather than a distant and uninterested God.
Not that the media would ever admit that.
Saturday, November 24, 2007
Gather round my children, and I will tell tales of war...
As Thanksgiving passes, we gather round and and tell stories of the endless war. Poverty? Drugs? Terror? Nope. The War on Christmas. Some may say that war is glorious, but "war is cruelty, and you cannot refine it." Sure Spielberg makes it look glorious, but you be the one trapped in vines of garland as glass ornaments explode above you. You try assaulting the Fortress of Good with nothing but some sharpened holly leaves, poison oak fashioned to resemble mistletoe, and evil godless intentions. Tell me stories of it now!
Okay, that may be overwrought, kinda like the seasonal cries of conservatives that there is a "war on Christmas" is on. The way that cantankerous would-be soldiers in this war wish you a "Merry Christmas" with chin out and nostrils flaring, just daring you to respond with an insufficient "Happy Holidays!" The mind games they play with store clerks making $7/hour who will probably get laid off in a month. And the thing of it all is, though I am proud and firm in my atheism, I agree with them. But for different reasons.
Because I think that it is time to liberate the word "Christmas" from the dusty, mournful still-life mishmash of early religious writers trying to fill in backstory to make even older religious writers seem prescient. Happily, our culture has writ the joyful trumpeting of angels across this feast.
We've drowned out the ominous observance of theSaturnalis Christmas to remember the virgin birth of baby Mithra Jesus born in Nazareth Bethlehem to one day die and rise again to save mankind as is the duty of Adonis the Son of Man. Because in 2007, America's Christmas is more, and I would say better than that.
I love the music of it, the lights. I love candy canes and yes -- mistletoe. I love this joyful conspiracy to fĂȘte a jolly man who gives freely to those deserving, and embodies humankind on its best. I love that the Grinch's heart grew three sizes that day, that Keith Lockhart conducts the heck out of a Christmas concert, that I'm almost in my 30s and still have a stocking. So yes, wish me a Merry Christmas.
That is worth celebrating. The goodness of man being kind to man, people smiling and wearing silly hats. And if I'm wrong and there is a Jesus, I imagine that he'd be pretty pleased with what his birthday has become.*
* Yes, I'm ignoring the excess consumerism that drives people to go to stores at 4am the day after Thanksgiving. I ignore it in this post, and I ignore it in my life. I don't let anybody ruin my Christmas, especially Madison Avenue. But if you want some Christmas humbuggery, here's some stand-up from Jim Gaffigan for ya.
His Easter stuff isn't as funny as Eddie Izzard's, though:
Okay, that may be overwrought, kinda like the seasonal cries of conservatives that there is a "war on Christmas" is on. The way that cantankerous would-be soldiers in this war wish you a "Merry Christmas" with chin out and nostrils flaring, just daring you to respond with an insufficient "Happy Holidays!" The mind games they play with store clerks making $7/hour who will probably get laid off in a month. And the thing of it all is, though I am proud and firm in my atheism, I agree with them. But for different reasons.
Because I think that it is time to liberate the word "Christmas" from the dusty, mournful still-life mishmash of early religious writers trying to fill in backstory to make even older religious writers seem prescient. Happily, our culture has writ the joyful trumpeting of angels across this feast.
We've drowned out the ominous observance of the
That is worth celebrating. The goodness of man being kind to man, people smiling and wearing silly hats. And if I'm wrong and there is a Jesus, I imagine that he'd be pretty pleased with what his birthday has become.*
* Yes, I'm ignoring the excess consumerism that drives people to go to stores at 4am the day after Thanksgiving. I ignore it in this post, and I ignore it in my life. I don't let anybody ruin my Christmas, especially Madison Avenue. But if you want some Christmas humbuggery, here's some stand-up from Jim Gaffigan for ya.
His Easter stuff isn't as funny as Eddie Izzard's, though:
Wednesday, November 14, 2007
Hollywood to 10% of America: go screw
The "free hand" of the market, my schuchis. I'm a progressive atheist, and ain't nobody serving me or my 30 million fellow freethinkers. Jon Stewart and Keith Olberman is all we got (and even that is only halfway) meanwhile the dingbats have cable channels, industries, and a conduit to a government jobs program through a "university" that offers a course on "The Christian Role in the Arts today". More on that later, but first, about books.
There are books, then there are books. There are books that are a good read, something to make a subway ride go by quickly. There are books perfect for rainy Saturdays (I remember an entirely satisfying rain-pelt weekend plowing through The Years of Rice and Salt by Kim Stanley Robinson) and short vacations.
Then there are books. Books where you have to put the object down to savor the story. Books where part of you wants to sniff the page, because the prose is so electric that the paper itself should be transformed. When I think of the idea of a book, my mind goes to Philip Pullman's textured, dolent and fearless trilogy His Dark Materials.
The story as a whole is sweeping, and is a moving indictment of organized religion. The characters strive to tear down the Kingdom of Heaven, and replace it with a "Republic of Heaven". In the process, you have armored polar-bears, soulful witches, fearless miniscule spies, all leading up to some bittersweet.
But enough of that, let's go into the story. I won't go so far as snopes.com and call the books "anti-religion" but they certainly don't swallow religion as a system whole. A recent treatment in Atlantic Monthly matches what we've seen from elsewhere: a desperate Hollywood, deathly afraid of Bullies with Bibles., shaved off the parts of the book that question religion (naturally, this didn't please the whining brats, who still stamp their feet at such horrid freethought running amok)
On a personal level, this is horrid. I love these books, and while I did not expect a 100% faithful (heh) adaptation, I was hoping that enough of the story would be preserved that I would be able to enjoy the cinematography in peace. Instead, they ripped out the series' center and meaning. This is The Lion, The Witch, and the Wardrobe without Aslan coming back to life, Citizen Kane without the sled, The Wizard of Oz without a Yellow Brick Road.
But can someone explain to me why it was so horrid that a movie with a huge built-in audience (the series is number 42 on the Barnes & Noble best-seller list) should remain true to the story? So horrid that a movie that discusses theology rather than ignores it or venerates it be made? That a movie that beautifully draws a world following the beliefs of about 30 million or so non-theists in this country be allowed to exist? Is evil atheist pop Hollywood that scared of a bunch that are only happy when they're sulking and being offended? I've waited 5 years for the movie, and we get...this.
Which stinks.
I wish there was a happier ending, but there isn't. Which makes sense, because being an atheist in modern America...
stinks.
(PS: If you love the Narnia books, and are of stout heart, read Pullman's essay about them.)
There are books, then there are books. There are books that are a good read, something to make a subway ride go by quickly. There are books perfect for rainy Saturdays (I remember an entirely satisfying rain-pelt weekend plowing through The Years of Rice and Salt by Kim Stanley Robinson) and short vacations.
Then there are books. Books where you have to put the object down to savor the story. Books where part of you wants to sniff the page, because the prose is so electric that the paper itself should be transformed. When I think of the idea of a book, my mind goes to Philip Pullman's textured, dolent and fearless trilogy His Dark Materials.
The story as a whole is sweeping, and is a moving indictment of organized religion. The characters strive to tear down the Kingdom of Heaven, and replace it with a "Republic of Heaven". In the process, you have armored polar-bears, soulful witches, fearless miniscule spies, all leading up to some bittersweet.
On a personal level, this is horrid. I love these books, and while I did not expect a 100% faithful (heh) adaptation, I was hoping that enough of the story would be preserved that I would be able to enjoy the cinematography in peace. Instead, they ripped out the series' center and meaning. This is The Lion, The Witch, and the Wardrobe without Aslan coming back to life, Citizen Kane without the sled, The Wizard of Oz without a Yellow Brick Road.
But can someone explain to me why it was so horrid that a movie with a huge built-in audience (the series is number 42 on the Barnes & Noble best-seller list) should remain true to the story? So horrid that a movie that discusses theology rather than ignores it or venerates it be made? That a movie that beautifully draws a world following the beliefs of about 30 million or so non-theists in this country be allowed to exist? Is evil atheist pop Hollywood that scared of a bunch that are only happy when they're sulking and being offended? I've waited 5 years for the movie, and we get...this.
Which stinks.
I wish there was a happier ending, but there isn't. Which makes sense, because being an atheist in modern America...
stinks.
(PS: If you love the Narnia books, and are of stout heart, read Pullman's essay about them.)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)